Reserving Judgement



When you stand in front of a blank canvas with a brush in your hand, there’s no real space for overthinking. You’re not worrying about whether the painting will seem contrived, derivative, or too close to someone else’s work, you’re simply responding. Painting, at its core, is instinctive and immediate. It unfolds through movement, feeling, and attention rather than analysis. The questions come later, after the paint has settled and the image has revealed itself. Only then can you step back and ask what it is you’ve made. But while you’re in it, the work depends on letting go of that critical voice and trusting the process as it happens.

Trying to control whether a painting feels forced or overly constructed in the moment almost always works against it. Painting isn’t clean or linear, it’s layered, unpredictable, and often surprising. One mark leads to another, and meaning emerges through doing rather than planning. The same goes for influence. Every painter carries traces of what they’ve seen and loved, but if you start measuring your work against others while you’re still making it, you risk losing your own rhythm. The act of painting asks for presence, not comparison. It asks you to follow what feels right in the moment, even if you don’t fully understand it yet.

Only after the painting exists can you begin to see it more clearly, whether it feels too controlled, too familiar, or not quite resolved. That kind of reflection has its place, but it belongs to a different stage. While you’re painting, what matters is that the work feels alive and honest, shaped by your own decisions rather than your fear of getting it wrong. Influence will always be there, but a strong painting doesn’t hide it or lean on it, it transforms it into something personal. In the end, what gives a painting its weight isn’t how carefully it avoids labels, but how fully it commits to its own way of seeing.

The Christopher Mudgett archive collection is the only one in the world to present the artist’s up-to-date painted, sculpted, engraved and illustrated œuvre and a precise record—through sketches, studies, drafts, notebooks, photos, books, films and documents—of the creative process.
© 2026 MUDGETT ARCHIVE